Burn Phoenix Burn
 

Director: Lily Liu
Year: 1982
Rating: 5.0


 By 1982 Taiwanese actress Brigitte Lin Ching-hsia was at a crossroads in her career with one foot in Taiwanese cinema and the other inching towards Hong Kong. Since her debut in 1973 at the age of 19 she had appeared in over 60 films and had been a huge star from that very first one. She was considered one of the Great Chinese Beauties and I would not argue with that. Eyes that can be as soft as a love poem or as cold and fierce as revenge. She can be entrancing with little more than shifting emotions on her face. But for this first decade of her career she had primarily made films in Taiwan that were either light comedies or tear inducing melodramas. There were a few exceptions to this though. 800 Hundred Heroes in 1975 about the Chinese fighting the Japanese, The Dream of the Red Chamber in 1977 was a period opera for Shaw Brothers (the only film she made for them) and Love Massacre in 1981 which is considered a classic in the Hong Kong New Wave. But the vast majority of her films had English titles like The House of Love, Love Love Love, He Loved Once Too Many, Run Love Run and The Love Affair of Rainbows. But these corny films had made her a star throughout the Chinese communities around the world. I have watched a number of these films and only for one reason. Brigitte.



But now she was approaching 30 and though still stunning, it was perhaps time to change her image. You can't play love sick heroines forever. In this same year, she appeared in two Taiwanese films that are nearly inexplicable in her filmography. Was it just a matter of her wanting to do something entirely different or were the triads somehow involved. I don't know but she made two gnarly over the top insane really cheesy but wonderful female action films. You have to see them to believe them - Pink Force Commando and Golden Queens Commandos. I hope not too many of her fan base went in expecting broken hearts and love songs. It was a very peculiar choice but perhaps a decision that changed the trajectory of her career and made her an even bigger star. Maybe the biggest star in Hong Kong and beyond for about ten years. In the following year she dove right into the heart of Hong Kong films with the clever comedy All the Wrong Spies and more importantly in the Tsui Hark fantasy classic Zu: The Warriors from Magic Mountain where she plays the Ice Queen in glorious fashion. That led to iconic roles in films like Peking Opera Blues, Police Story, Swordsman II, Dragon Inn, The East is Red, The Bride with White Hair, Chungking Express and her final film, the amazing Ashes of Time. She retired at the top.



And thank goodness for her change of cinematic personality if Burn Phoenix Burn is to go by. This is emotionally as flat as a pancake. If anything the Taiwanese were great at making these complicated melodramas that had all the middle aged women in the audience sniffling. Even me on occasion. But this one can't seem to make up its mind whether to go for a light comedy or a melodrama and ends up with neither. Just a story. The makings were there but one of the few female directors at the time, Lily Liu, didn't go in for the kill. She directed a few other Brigitte weepies so it is surprising.



The story begins with two little sisters playing on the swing and one pushes her younger sister too hard and she falls off and loses her sight. Jump 15 years into the future. The blind sister Chao-mei (Shirley Lui) plays the piano, is devoted to her sister and parents but fearful about life. The other sister Yen-jan (Brigitte) feels enormous guilt for what happened and is devoted to her. To such an extent that when she brings her boyfriend Ling Kang home (Liu Wen-cheng) she doesn't seem to mind that he immediately falls for her 16-year old sister (yes, he dumps Brigitte Lin for a 16-year old) . Jump ahead another five years - Brigitte meets an annoying man Master An (Yun Chung-yueh) at the library, he courts her and they fall in love (definitely not Brigitte worthy). There are a few speed bumps but really nothing to stop this from a happy ending. I kept waiting for the tragedy to come - the blind sister runs out and gets run over or she gets hit on the head and gets her sight back or she falls in love with her sister's new boyfriend or she sleeps with the wrong guy. Something. Anything. But what we do get is Brigitte laughing, gurgling, singing, dancing, crying, getting hysterical and simply looking lovely. For some of us, that is enough.