City Under Siege
     
                 
Director: Benny Chan
Year:  2010
Rating: 5.5

I like to give credit when a film tries to go for something new. Mutant super heroes and villains. Ok, sure it has been done way too often in the West but this is Hong Kong's crack at the genre. It is directed by Benny Chan who before his passing in 2020 helmed some of Hong Kong's better looking action films - Big Bullet, New Police Story, A Moment of Romance, Shaolin, Magic Crane and the Gen-Y and X films. I have not seen the ones that he made just prior to his death but I believe both The White Storm and Call of Heroes have a solid reputation. I just saw Shaolin last week and came away very impressed and so wanted to check this one out and hopefully White Storm and Call of Heroes soon. This is a real hit and miss film - it is like a mutant not fully formed as if Chan just didn't really know what he had on his hands or where to go with it. Make it a romance? Make it a comedy? Make it a tragedy? Or a CGI action spectacle? None of them really work. It is like a guy out on a drinking binge and as the night goes along he gets stupider and stupider until he ends up in the gutter wondering what happened the night before. Of course, many super hero films are downright low on the IQ scale. I thought Venom was one of the worst films I have ever seen it reeks with so much idiocy. Aquaman was not far behind. This one is not Venom stupid but Chan gives it his best.




It starts off reasonably good though - Chan had nearly a solid first hour going for him before he falls off the cliff and turns it into a laughable lachrymose mess. It is worth sticking around to the bitter end in the nearly two hour film just to see how bad it gets with the pièce de résistance at the very end. I just literally shook my head in disbelief that this was made by Chan. But before we get to that he has a few decent if overly dependent on CGI and wires action set pieces. I thought they were quite well done and as bombastic and chaotic as you could want. With a couple players from the old days who know their martial arts.



Let's see where to start. In a prologue it is 1945 in Malaysia and the Japanese are in an underground bunker trying to create a super solider. But before they do the Brits find them and blow the bunker up. Jump to the present time - a circus run by a terribly underutilized Yuen Wah has some very cool acts - one is the Flying Dagger routine - throwing knives at a person on a pinwheel from various positions. The Flying Dagger man is played by Ngai Sing, a real stalwart of action films in the 1990s - almost always as the villain. The MC is Aaron Kwok in a clown costume who is slightly dimwitted until he suddenly seems smarter at the end. He wants to do Flying Daggers because his dad wanted him to. But he is totally incompetent. He plays his role like a ten-year old who has never been outside.




One night he sees a group from the circus sneak off and follows them. They are looking for gold - instead they find the chemicals that the Japanese were working with. They all including Kwok inhale it and within minutes begin to gain powers. And in Kwok's case a ton of weight - he must have borrowed Andy Lau's fat suit from Love on a Diet. Later Sing may have used Andy's muscle suit from Running on Karma. They all end up in Hong Kong where the circus boys and girl (Karen Cheung) use their powers to go on a rampage of theft and murder. Kwok who was separated from them gets a ride on the highway from . . . Shu Qi! Some guys have all the luck. She takes him home as a fat man but by the next day we have Aaron Kwok back as gallons of water have leaked out of his body. Thank goodness. He shortly runs into Shu Qi again when she as a reporter is covering a hostage situation. From half a mile away he sends a small stick through the glass window that cuts into the hostage taker. She sees a story.




Back at his place she is interviewing him when the Boys show up because they are mutating into monsters and what is the point of having powers and money if no girls will go out with you because you look like something they dragged up from a swamp. They want his blood. A big action scene kicks in and into this comes Jacky Wu and his female assistant Zhang Jing-chu. We never quite figure out who they are - but they seem to be mutant hunters. Huh? Are there other mutants? Is that a full time job? Shu Qi films the big fight and puts it on the Internet - and this is when the film suddenly truly goes to hell. Kwok starts doing commercials, Sing falls in love with Shu Qi (can any one blame him) and wants to date her, she starts to fall for the mentally deficient Kwok. The film just dies on the operating table. It gets so ridiculous. But wait for that ending. Yikes.