This film had the feel of many of those old Hollywood
war films made during WWII full of valor, personal sacrifice, wooden
characters and lots of flag waving. In this film, the flag waving is literal
as well as figurative. The story takes place during the Japanese invasion
of Shanghai in 1937 and it relates the Chinese opposition. The film was
produced in Taiwan and there clearly seems to be more at hand here than
simply re-creating an event in Chinese history.
Still this is not a bad war film. It has a
large cast and budget and had a wide scope as it details the action from
the beginning of the Japanese invasion until the Chinese forces are driven
out of Shanghai. I cant think of too many other Chinese films that are
war films in this manner. There is no kung-fu involved it is a war film
very much along the lines of those from the west except it is the Chinese
wiping out waves of Japanese soldiers instead of the US Marines. Some large
scale battles are mixed with some individual acts of heroism.
The film focuses primarily on a few characters
- Chin Yuan who leads the resistance and his wife (Hsu Feng) and Brigitte
Lin who is a Girl Scout. Brigitte looks amazingly young here and has a
few emotional scenes that she plays quite well.
The Japanese begin by bombing the city and then
lead an amphibious assault. The Chinese under Chin Yuan resist bravely,
but the firepower of the Japanese slowly pushes them back. Finally 800
soldiers hold up in a warehouse and refuse to give up to overwhelming numbers.
They hold out for days as the Japanese repeatedly attack and get
Brigitte is not unfortunately one of the 800.
I was certainly hoping she would be. Instead as I mentioned she is a Girl
Scout but she is not selling cookies. She has found refuge along with
thousands of other Chinese in the British settlement in Shanghai. As you
know, the foreign powers back then had appropriated areas of the city as
their own. Here the refugees are safe, as the Japanese could not enter
those areas. Brigitte helps organize things within the camps and on two
occasions supplies the embattled troops at the risk of her own life. She
has two good emotional moments in the film when she gets to emote. Once
when her parents demand that she leave with them and she gets down on her
knees and begs to stay and not be dishonored. Then later she takes the
flag to the troops first swimming across the river, then dodging bullets
and is hailed as a hero and has a song written about her!
Just remember that these troops were Nationalist
troops loyal to Chang Kai Shek and the flag that so many people die for
is the Nationalist flag. Pure cornball patriotic flag waving stuff but
effective to some degree. There are some good emotional moments in the
film. Hsu Feng one of my favorite actresses of late through her work
for King Hu is terrific as the loving and loyal wife and Sylvia
Chang (also amazingly young looking) has one great scene where she gives
a speech crying out for revenge against the Japanese. So this film has
three of the very best Taiwanese actresses but the film really focuses
for the main part on Chin Yuan and the 800 heroes.
The film is based on a true incident that took
place in 1937 and Brigitte's character is based on a real person as well.
In the West the 800 Heroes were known as the Lost Battalion (thanks to
Chris for sending me this information). The story was also filmed in 1938
with the same title and here is what writer Bono Lee had to say about the
incident in the book "A Century of Chinese Cinema".
"The film chronicles a famous incident, which
took place at the onset of the Sino-Japanese War, when the Japanese army
invaded Shanghai and the foreign concessions quickly declared neutrality.
To facilitate the Nationalist Army's retreat down the Suzhou River, Xie
Junyuan, Commander of the 88th division, led his 800 soldiers in a heroic
defense of a warehouse in Shanghai's Zhabei district. Stranded, outnumbered
and under continuous fire, they held their ground for four days despite
suffering heavy casulties. Their courageous stance and miraculous survival
against odds became a symbolic manifestation of the city and the nation's
will to defend their homeland.
This culminates in the historic incident when
a girl scout, Yang Huimin, braves enemy fire to swim across the river to
deliver a Nationalist flag to the soldiers."