Director: Johannes Guter
Year: 1929
Country: Germany
Rating: 7.0
Aka - Her
Dark Secret
Aka - Ihr Dunkler Punkt
This silent Weimar film is a charming romantic
comedy bubble that never pops. It has two of the biggest stars of the period
with Lilian Harvey and Willy Fritsch who were in eleven films together and
were called the "dream couple" of German cinema. German cinema of the Weimar
era is often thought of today for the expressionistic style, the off-kilter
camera angles and sets that were nightmares of imagination and psychosis.
Famous for its horror and sci-fi, but more popular were the comedies and
when sound was introduced, the musicals. Harvey and Fritsch were part of
that world and their films together did very well. It is easy to see why
after seeing this one and Lucky Kids a few months ago. He is dashing and
she is a bundle of barely contained joy. She is like the first coke of the
day. She wasn't able to navigate through the Hitler years - she wasn't Jewish
but among her friends were both Jews and homosexuals and she was put on the
SS watch list as a suspected person. She spoke German, English and French
(some of her films were shot in all three languages with her) and she made
her escape to France and then when the Germans invaded left for the USA.
Her final film in Germany was made in 1939, then two in France and she retired
from the film business for good. She had actually made a few films earlier
in the decade in Hollywood, but none of them made her a star. Such a shame
because she is delight.
Here she plays two roles - Lilian who is
an upper middle-class woman with a zest for life - and Yvette who is jewel
thief and seducer of men. When Lilian checks into a hotel in Germany she
is arrested because she looks exactly like Yvette - except for a mole on
her thigh and while Yvette has dark hair, she has blonde hair. When
she is released with the help of her cousin, Leopold (Harry Halm), she learns
from Erik (Fritsch) who thinks she is Yvette, that he will meet her in Naples.
Just for the hell of it, Lilian decides to go to Naples and pretend to be
Yvette and drags her reluctant cousin along.
Of course, Yvette is there with her three
male henchmen who are planning to steal diamonds off of Eric when he arrives.
This all leads to lots of confusion and mistaken identities. As Yvette, Lilian
has to take on her role as part of a magic act having no idea what she is
supposed to do. In her sparkling cat suit, she is so cute and very funny.
Harvey is wonderful in both roles - as Lilian she is adorable and sweet and
as Yvette she is sexual dynamite with an ability to get any man she wants.
At one point two of her gang are fighting over which one Yvette loves and
in the same room, she is able to convince them both that she loves them and
only them. Comical and sophisticated, I was hoping for a few musical numbers
but not in this one.