Director: Amanda Nell Eu
Year: 2023
Country: Malaysia
Rating: 7.0
This coming-of-age
film touches on a myriad of subjects from puberty to bullying to friendships,
parental conflict, religious conservatism and societal taboos - all under
the cover of a folk-horror tale. The transgressiveness of the film right
from the beginning is particularly surprising in that it was made in Islamic
Malaysia which is very strict in what is allowed to be depicted. And in fact,
the version seen in that country was highly censured. From what I have read
they censored scenes of dancing, blood on a tampon, the taking off of the
school-girls Abaya, the trying on of a brassiere on top of her clothes. Things
that would go unnoticed in a film from The West but are asking for trouble
in a country like Malaysia. While watching the film it is difficult to discern
how much of it is real, how much fantasy, how much are dreams, how much is
symbolism, how much the imagination of a young girl under stress or even
how much is the perspective of the religious establishment. Is she being
seen and judged through their eyes. Or is this just a modern-day folk tale
of the Pontianak or a Penanggal, a story that will be told to scare children
late at night to behave correctly. On top of this is the fact that
the director is a female, Amanda Nell Eu, who went to film school in London.
Considering the content of the film - revolving around a girl's first menstruation,
that makes sense. It is a subject that men tend to stay away from.
Three eleven-year-old female friends - gather
in the woman's bathroom at school to frolic. Zaffan (Zafreen Zairizal) begins
a wild frantic dance that her two friends video on their phone. It is likely
that it is something she saw on TikTok. Then she takes off her Abaya revealing
her pants and shirt beneath. Already a breach of Islamic decorum. Then she
shows her friends that she is wearing a bra - and takes it off to allow her
friend Farah (Deena Ezral) to put it on over her clothes. Three close friends
in this rural town surrounded by the jungle. But then Zaffan gets her
first period and everything changes.
It puts her in a category from the other
girls. She no longer has to attend prayer at the school. She gets whelps
all over her body, omits a revolting odor that drives her friends away, sees
demons in the treetops. And begins to get a hunger. All of her friends at
school turn on her, bully her, humiliate her and there is a mass hysteria
that overcomes them. At home she gets no support from her parents. She is
going through body changes and has no one to talk to. She is able to scamper
up trees and rundown small animals. That hunger. But then the film confuses
us by having her back at school wearing her uniform in class - was it all
a dream, a fantasy, a wish. An Islamic exorcist is brought in by her father;
primarily because she has become so disobedient. The film moves slowly,
adding layers of disquiet but it never quite goes where you expect it to
or want it to. The horror is off screen. I am sure everyone wanted Farah
to become a meal. Instead, it goes into the mystic and you are not quite
sure what you have witnessed.