Maigret and the Dead Lover Film Review
Maigret and the Dead Lover
Director: Pascal
Bonitzer
Year:
2026
Rating: 6.0
Aka - Maigret et le Mort Amoureux
Simenon's Inspector Maigret is alive and
well. The pipe-smoking Inspector has had as many iterations as Sherlock Holmes.
For reasons that seem out of place in today's age. Rarely, a man of action,
he patiently mulls over cases, repeatedly questions suspects and witnesses,
is a father figure to the men underneath him, a faithful husband to his wife
who waits for him at home and slowly unravels the case and arrests the killer.
The books are of course wonderful. Every time I read one, I want to move
to Paris and spend my days sitting in cafes listening to French chansons
over apéritifs.
Being a fan of the books has translated
to watching as much Maigret as I can find; both film and TV. Ones that especially
stick out to me were the three films made during WWII starring Albert Préjean
as Maigret, the great Jean Gabin also in three films in the late 1950s, Gérard
Depardieu was a fine Maigret in one film a few years ago. But it is probably
TV where Maigret is best known. A few terrific series - Rupert Davies is
a great Maigret in 52 episodes in the early 1960s. Maigret himself said "At
last, I have found the perfect Maigret!". Other fine Maigret's were Michael
Gambon in 12 episodes and Bruno Cremer in a French version for 54 episodes.
And recently, Rowan Atkinson has taken on the role of the Inspector in four
TV movies and I admit I had trouble taking Mr. Bean seriously but have noted
that a lot of people on social media liked them. And yet another TV version
is being released with Benjamin Wainwright as Maigret. I have not seen any
but Wainwright is this young studly looking fellow, nothing like the Maigret
of the novels.
And now this French film released in 2026
starring Denis Podalydès. The film is not really up to snuff and neither
is Podalydès in truth. He is short and balding with zero charisma
or presence. It strikes me as an odd casting decision. Partly, I admit because
I have an image of Maigret as this large burly commanding man and this is
far off. Besides that the film just kind of moves along with no sense of
mystery or suspense. Maigret just interviews people and it is a simple mistake
by the perpetrator that leads to their arrest. No great insight. A wealthy
elderly man of means is found shot with five bullet holes in his study. The
back story is interesting. He had a forty year love affair with a Princess
that was never consummated as she was married. After her husband dies, it
seems that they will finally be together. And then he is killed. Related
or coincidence? Maigret's wife is played by the wonderful Irene Jacob (Red
Colour), but again she is nothing like the wife of the books.