This seems an appropriate time to revisit this
film. A reminder that we have been through this shit before. That civilized
people in suits can be monsters. That many just go along. That many believe
the lies and the hate speech. Yes, we are there again when the government
is asking people to inform on others. When fanatics with an agenda run over
people, destroy innocent lives. When people who know better, stay quiet.
And I have no doubt that we will also look back on this period with shame.
As we now do, the era of the Hollywood Blacklist. Fanatics, cowards and the
gullible informally put a large number of Hollywood actors, directors, producers
and writers on a list that made it impossible for them to get work. Whispered
that they were Red or sympathetic to Communism. Destroyed them with a few
words to the right people. In the 1930s, it had been almost fashionable to
be on the Left when the country was in the middle of the Great Depression
- capitalism was failing - and years later, a signed petition, a meeting
attended could get you on the list. Unless you named names. Became an informer
on your fellow actors and friends. Many did, many didn't.
This film approaches this subject initially
in a mildly comedic manner but slowly pushes it towards tragedy and a political
statement. It is directed by Martin Ritt and scripted by Walter Bernstein
who were both blacklisted for years. Bernstein was able to continue writing
scripts though by using other people - fronts - the subject of this film.
Ritt taught at the Actors Studio for five years to support himself after
being blacklisted. So, it is personal for these guys, but they stay far away
from making it polemic. It is sweet, funny in moments and sad - and it stars
Woody Allen in one of the few films in which he neither wrote nor directed.
But he still plays the same sort of character he often did. Bernstein and
Ritt clearly had Allen in mind for the character. A bit of a nobody - smart,
fast of mouth but ignorant of everything around him but the horses that he
bets on - and usually loses.
He plays Howard Prince, a cashier in a restaurant
when his friend from elementary school, Alfred Miller (Michael Murphy) asks
him for a favor. Miller is a successful TV writer but has found himself suddenly
on the outs because of his progressive views. He needs Prince to pretend
to write scripts and be paid by the TV station for them. He will get 10%.
It works like a gem - Prince is able to pass off the writings as his own
- one of the producers (Andrea Marcovicci) falls for him and he adds two
more writers (one who was blacklisted). He is suddenly a star, hailed for
his writing and he likes it. The main producer is played by Herschel Bernardi
- also blacklisted - and the star is played by the great Zero Mostel, also
blacklisted. In the film he is blacklisted again. It is this that sucks the
comedy out of the film and makes it serious. These were real people who were
destroyed. Allen is surprisingly good as he evolves from schlep to a man
of conscious. Something sadly lacking in our politics today.