The Luzhin Defense


     

Director: Marleen Gorris
Year: 2000
Rating: 5.0

I expect for one to enjoy a romantic melodrama you have to care about the characters. I can't say I did. Adapted from Nabokov, it is missing that certain element that makes you want for these people to end up together. That is quite preposterous really. Emily Watson plays the daughter of an upper class family who finds herself on vacation where a chess tournament is taking place circa the late 1920's. There she finds herself drawn to a totally mentally broken chess player (John Turturro) who can barely put a sentence together, has no ability to care about anything but chess and who is a total bore. But she falls in love with him and he with her and my basic reaction was - why? Really why? He is basically a milder nicer version of Bobby Fischer - unable to relate to the real world and it to him. I read somewhere that the final chess solution in the film is in reality quite brilliant. It may possibly have been derived from Nabokov who created these chess puzzles and was quite a fine player.