Elmer, The Great


Director: Mervyn LeRoy
Year: 1935
Rating: 5.0


The Cubs win the World Series! The Cubs win the World Series! At least they do in this little quaint comedy from 1933. I bet they never guessed that in fact they would not win it again until 2016 - some 108 years after they won it in 1908 when they won it for the second year in a row. This is a baseball film that I had never heard of even though it has some nice authorship around it - Ring Lardner (father of Ring Lardner Jr.) and none other than frigging George M. Cohan. Directing it is Mervyn Leroy who spun out such classics of the time as Little Caesar, I was a Fugitive from a Chain Gang, Gold Diggers of 1933 and so many more. It also stars one of the top comedians of the time - Joe E. Brown. Joe E. Brown is a legend of sorts but I admit that as far as I can recall the only other thing I have seen him in was as the wealthy guy in Some Like it Hot who uttered the famous line "Well, nobody's perfect" when he finds out his girl is a guy (Jack Lemmon). In the early 1930's he was a huge star with Warner's and even had in his contract that there had to be a baseball team on hand to play with between shoots. But he left Warner in 1937 and his career slumped considerably afterwards.



An interesting aspect of the film - though I would assume totally accidental - is its similarity to the great baseball film The Natural. Elmer is a great if reluctant hitter in love with his hometown girl but goes off to play with the Cubs and gets involved with gamblers but comes back to win the Series with a home run. It is more a bit of nostalgia than a funny film - maybe humor has changed since then.