Director: Savage Steve Holland
Year: 1985
Rating: 7.0
The teenage movie hit its high water mark in the 1980's. They usually but
certainly not always fell into two sub-genres - the broken-hearted or love
from a distance romance films that seemed to always star the adorable Molly
Ringwald or the Virginity films in which the male protagonist is desperately
trying to lose his - sometimes successfully; often not. There were a few
more serious teenage films as well - sort of in the teenage angst category
- Stand By Me and Coppola's Rumble Fish and the Outsiders come to mind. There
were also the odd-ball films like Ferris Bueller, Risky Business and Fast
Times at Ridgemont High. I guess they must still be making teenage films
but I can't say I ever see them because they generally are about teenagers
being stuck somewhere with a mad killer getting them one by one in as gruesome
a way as the director can imagine. Those started in seriousness in the 1990's
and have not stopped.
And though Better Off Dead had many of the elements that a lot of the broken-hearted
teenage films had - the popular blonde girlfriend ditches him, the nerdy
wise-cracking friend, the school bully, the embarrassing moments in high
school, the out of touch silly parents, the comical attempts at suicide,
the unnoticed girl next door, the main character's redemption, the . . .
err - let me back up a bit - the comical attempts at suicide? Yes, with an
original tagline of "Sometimes . . . you're Better Off Dead" the film with
its mocking absurdist irreverent tone manages to avoid falling neatly into
any category. The director and writer Savage Steve Holland had apparently
tried killing himself after a break-up as a teenager and years later used
that as the inspiration for this film.
Not that it's really the centerpiece of the film - he only tries it a few
times in no meaningful way - and like so much of this film making light of
suicide would not be cool today. As is true of the two Asian brothers, one
of who can only speak like Howard Cosell, the overweight creepy near sex
offender cheered on by his mother, the accidental pulling down the dress
of a woman in the lunch cafeteria and so on. The 1980's were a lot more non-PC
and especially many of the more raucous teenage grotty a smattering of nudity
get laid films.
This film just lives in an absurd nonsensical world in which the main character
can get nothing right - every thing he does gets screwed up from various
car accidents to trying to hit on the basket ball's team's groupie to accidentally
serving a woman paint thinner to which she lights a cigarette have no real
life consequences. He just seems to sail through it all unconcerned and un-punished
- and though a dweeb on so many levels he is still sort of the cool dweeb
- and the film is able to pull this off because the main character is played
by a very young John Cusack. Cusack starred in a few of these teenage films
- the most famous being Say Anything but he always has an intelligent wry
characterization going on. Ironically, the producers did not want Cusack
for the role as he wasn't well known at the time, but the director fought
for him and it is hard to imagine any other young actor at the time who could
have brought this off.
In this one as Lane Meyer he is obsessed with his status driven girlfriend
who has every intention of dumping Lane because he is not popular enough
and has a crappy car. He takes it hard. Especially when everyone from a teacher
(a wonderful Vincent Schiavelli) to the postman ask him if it is ok that
they date his ex. She ends up in the arms of the top skier and an all around
asshole. He thinks he can win her back by beating said asshole in a ski race
down a suicidal ski run. In the background is the cute French exchange student
that we all know is the girl for him. Mainly because she has a cute accent
and has curly hair.
The final fifteen minutes of the film gives it to the stereotype Broken Hearted
Guy film ending but until then it is full of very funny bits that often slip
by unnoticed - the pig fetus in the jar that his friend carries around with
him, the baby food that the basket ball players are eating, the awful goopy
meals his mother (Kim Darby) keeps making, one of which crawls off his plate,
his younger brother who has a roomful of hot women, the pictures of his girlfriend
on every piece of wall space not to mention as coat hangers, that moment
when you first meet a girl and you worry you have a bugger on your nose,
the psychotic newspaper boy who breaks all their windows and wants his $2,
the father (David Ogden Stiers) who thinks he has outsmarted the news boy,
the classroom wildly enthusiastic about geometry. There are some very funny
moments in here that had me cracking up and though in these PC times and
at my age I almost feel weird watching a teenage love story (which isn't
exactly Romeo and Juliet) this was a good one.